WebTo be eligible for CME credit, a review must be rated at 40 or above according to the criteria below. In general, a review must demonstrate a depth and scope that require a review of the literature and knowledge of the evidence base for the manuscript reviewed. In your review, please provide evidence that you have reviewed the pertinent WebMar 21, 2024 · In 2016, we discontinued the use of “reject-and-resubmit” at the Journal of Finance. After giving the issue some thought, we came to the conclusion that “rejects-and-resubmits” are detrimental to a transparent and predictable editorial process: 1. Since “reject-and-resubmit” does not exist as a formal decision category (formally, it ...
How to deal with revise and resubmit to an academic journal - CW …
WebJul 20, 2014 · HR can offer some guidance on the best way to deliver the review. On the other side, if you’re an employee expecting a bad review, go talk with HR about your concerns and get some guidance on how to respond in a constructive manner. DURING the review. The manager can give an employee the option of delivering their rebuttal to HR or … how to say yes in japan
peer review - Should I appeal my paper
WebDec 6, 2024 · This week, Jeniffer Jeyakumar, Senior Editorial Assistant at F1000Research explains the process of re-reviewing. Peer review should be a collaborative process which involves the joint effort of both reviewers and authors working towards the goal of improving the overall quality of the paper. Re-reviewing begins when the authors of an article ... Web1. Before accepting review invitation, what should reviewers consider? Before accepting the review invitation, reviewers must inform the Associate Editor if they hold a conflict of interests that may prejudice the review report. Examples of conflicts of interest may include relationships with academic advisors and/or advisees; anyone at WebNov 24, 2013 · In Gerrit, if there's a problem with one of my commits, comments are left on it and it receives a non-positive score. With a Pull Request comments can be left on it and it can be declined. In Gerrit, to address the issues the comments raised I amend the offending commit (s) and push them up again (well, new commits with the same Change-Id). how to say yes in persian